Air Warfare

To counter drones, Army seeks layers rather than ‘silver bullets’

The Army is looking for industry ideas, but Ukraine has shown it'll take more than just one tactic.

Eyes to the Sky
Marines with 2nd Battalion, 1st Marines, participate in Counter-Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) training in the United States Central Command area of operations. (Marine Corps/Gunnery Sgt. Melissa Marnell)

AUSA 2022 — The conflict in Ukraine has only reinforced and crystalized an important lesson for the US military: They’ll need more than one option to counter the growing threat from unmanned systems.

The threats are diverse, ranging from sophisticated, long-range cruise missiles to off-the-shelf quadcopters, and therefore the defenses must be as well, according to Maj. Gen. Sean A. Gainey, director of the Army’s Counter-Unmanned Aircraft Systems Office.

Gainey said this is no “silver bullet,” and that an effective counter-drone (cUAS) strategy will depend on a “layered approach” to defenses, whether it’s kinetic, electronic, directed energy or microwave systems, and called on industry to present their own ideas so the service can work them into the layers.

“When you get to volume, how do you get a range of systems that respond to volume?” he asked, before quickly reassuring the audience at the annual Association of the United States Army conference that the Army already does have some potent drone defenses.

Gainey noted that the electronic systems work “pretty good” against smaller unmanned systems, but he has previously said that the rise of autonomy in unmanned operations has limited the effectiveness of EW as “now you’re not cutting a link.”

RELATED: The ‘Kinetic Pendulum’: How the Army wants to defeat drone threats

Today Gainey suggested it’s still been difficult to convince some stakeholders that cUAS is as serious of a problem as he sees it, especially for the smaller, quadcopter-type threats.

“There are some that will believe that it’s more of a hazard,” he said. But the Army has to “not look at it as a hazard, but a threat.”

One place the US has seen the threat, Gainey said, was at Central Command — a threat that “retriculates into Ukraine.” That appears to be a reference to Iran’s unmanned capabilities, which have long concerned US officials (and others) in the Middle East and have been exported to Russian forces.

But while Gainey and his fellow officials spent time pitching to industry to help come up with creative cUAS solutions, they also focused on another key aspect of the Army’s cUAS initiative: training.

Currently there’s a cUAS “academy” out in Yuma, Ariz., but that’s a two-week-long course. The panelists said they aim to expand it as part of a broader effort to spread counter-drone knowledge across the service. There soldiers — and airmen, Marines, Secret Service agents and whoever else wants to come — learn to use “electronic drone busters to scramble their navigation and send them flying back to whoever is controlling them,” according to an Army article.

But despite the urgency with which the Army is trying to move, Gainey said they envision a new, three-week course standing up not before fiscal year 2025.

AUSA 2022

AUSA 2022

Over at Rheinmetall's booth sat the hefty Lynx OMFV (Optionally Manned Fighting Vehicle). The company, as its competitors, is hoping to make a strong impression as the Army looks for OMFV proposals later this fall -- the early stage of an almost certainly lucrative long-term contract award. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
All the way from down under, the Australian firm Defendtex presented some of its modular UAVs. Here visitors can see the Drone155, which the company says can be outfitted with ISR payloads or explosives. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
The MVPP from Globe Tech stands for Modular Vehicle Protection Platform, a vehicle add-on that can take the brunt of improvised explosive device detonations. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
AUSA was well attended by international officers and officials as well, and by foreign defense firms. The Korean booth, shown here, featured some products hoping to make a splash in the US military. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
Not your traditional defense contractor, the computing giant IBM has a booth at AUSA showing off its flashy but functional quantum computer. The US government as a whole, and the Pentagon in particular, are heavily invested in the quantum computing race with the likes of China. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
Among the fleet of vehicles parked throughout the AUSA floor for display was the Flyer 72-U, made by General Dynamics. The company says the vehicle takes a "modular approach" so it can be configured for anything from "light strike assault" to rescue and evacuation. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
The stuff of counter-UAS nightmares, the Virginia-based BlueHalo firm makes drone swarms that use AI and machine learning to provide battlefield intelligence to soldiers. The Army's Rapid Capabilities and Critical Technologies Office awarded the company $14 million in February to develop the HIVE. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
It's a .50 caliber Gatling gun, one that Dillon Aero says can fire 1,500 shots per minute, or 25 rounds per second. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
For this year's show AM General rolled its own Humvee Saber, Blade Edition, onto the floor. The company claims "leap-ahead" technology for a light tactical vehicle. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
Patria, a defense firm owned jointly by Finland and Norway's Kongsberg Defence & Aerospace, made it's way across the Atlantic for AUSA 2022, bringing along its AMV multi-role vehicle. The AMV was recently purchased by the dozens by Slovakia and its home country of Finland. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
At the Pratt Miller Defense booth, visitors will see a full-sized Expeditionary Modular Autonomous Vehicle (EMAV) is the "newest and perhaps most mobile and lethal" of the company's autonomous offerings. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
Marathon's Autonomous Robot Targets are exactly what that sounds like: shooting targets guided by computer code and designed to "look, move, and even behave like people," the company says. The robots were on the move on the AUSA floor -- though no shooting was allowed. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
The AUSA show floor offered a fresh look at a futuristic version of an old Army standby: the Abrams tank. This one, the Abrams X, is made by General Dynamics Land Systems, manufacturers of the current Abrams M1A1 and M1A2 battle tanks used by the US Army. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
Attendees may walk by model versions of the famous Iron Dome system, in use for years in Israel, and its sister SkyCeptor system, both made by Rafael. The SkyCeptor, in particular, is meant to "defeat short- to medium-range ballistic and cruise missiles and other advanced air defense threats," the company says. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
As the need for counter-UAS systems explodes, Epirus is at AUSA repping its counter-electronics system Stryker Leonidas, made with General Dynamics. The system's "counter-swarm" weapon "fills a pressing short range air defense (SHORAD) capability gap," the company says. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
A new unveiling for AUSA, Rheinmetall announced this week the Mission Master CXT platform, the newest addition to the company's "family" of autonomous ground vehicles. The company says the CXT "combines the power of a diesel engine with a silent electric motor." (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).
The GMC Hummer EV Platform, the first vehicle on GM's New Ultium EV Platform, goes on display at AUSA 2022. All-electric offerings are the center of much of the Army's attention these days as it aims to electrify its non-tactical, and eventually tactical, fleet. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
Two new Armored Multi-Purpose Vehicles (AMPV) sit at the booth by Bae Systems. The vehicles are meant to replace the Army's venerable, but old M113s. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
Palantir shows off its prototype for the Tactical Intelligence Targeting Access Node (TITAN) vehicle. The company says the TITAN "will be the critical backbone that provides correlation, fusion, and integration of sensor data alongside insights from AI/ML overlaid at the tactical edge." In other words, it's meant to find the signal in the noise. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
A model of a "modernized" Boeing Apache AH-64E shown Association of US Army Conference in 2022. While the Army is about to choose two new airframes, there's currently no Apache replacement on the horizon. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
Lockheed Martin teamed up with Sikorsky to produce the Raider X, the team's competitor in the Army's Future Attack Reconnaissance Aircraft (FARA) program, one of two high-profile Army Future Vertical Lift contests currently underway. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
The Bell 360 Invictus is the other FARA competitor, looking to beat out the Lockheed-Sikorsky team. The Army's expected to make its decision in fiscal 2024. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
The defense start-up Anduril has expanded its footprint in the defense market in recent years. This product, the Mobile Sentry, "brings autonomous fixed site counter UAS and counter intrusion capabilities into a mobile form factor," the company says. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith)
The military's no-so-furry friendly robot dogs are back at AUSA this year. This model, called the Vision 60 Q-UGV from Ghost Robotics, is an "all-weather ground robot for use in a broad range of unstructured urban and natural environments for defense, homeland and enterprise applications," the company says. (Breaking Defense/Brendon Smith).