Naval Warfare

HII gets Navy’s green light to expand use of 3D printed parts in shipyards

An HII executive told Breaking Defense the NAVSEA certification will open the door for other alloys to be approved for use.

BATAAN SAILORS ATTEND 3D PRINTING COURSE
Fireman Dalton Garret, assigned to the Wasp-class amphibious assault ship USS Bataan (LHD 5) Engineering Department, produces a computer aided draft for a three-dimensional printing project, Nov. 16, 2022. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Matthew F. Brown)

SEA AIR SPACE 2023 — Naval Sea Systems Command has given HII the green light to begin using certain stainless steel, 3D printed materials in its shipyards, a key approval that a company executive says will open the door to more broadly using additive manufacturing across naval platforms.

The certification, which the company announced early last month, allows for HII to begin using a stainless steel alloy known as “316/316L” to produce pipefittings and other components on aircraft carriers and submarines.

But John Ralls, deputy chief engineer for additive manufacturing for Newport News Shipbuilding, told Breaking Defense in an interview leading up to the Sea Air Space exposition the approval has greater implications.

He described the steps for using 3D-printed components boils down to four elements: the processes and procedures for manufacturing it; the materials being employed; the people operating the equipment and the application or use case. All four elements needed to get individual approval from the Navy before HII could move forward with using the components in question.

“The significance of the qualification in the [announcement] is, those first three elements… the roadblocks that are necessary to overcome for deployment have effectively been answered,” he said. “The process and procedures are approved. The material has been sufficiently demonstrated to show the right level of technical rigor has been performed and… the operator that uses those [things] has demonstrated a level of proficiency.”

It’s an incremental step, but an important one, Ralls said, if the company wants to continue looking at different materials to help bolster the supply chain for building various Navy vessels.

Additive manufacturing in the context of the defense industrial base has been a long, slow burn. Military brass have frequently discussed it as a method for bolstering supply chains that may have eroded over time or providing sailors with quick fixes to problems while forward deployed — such as aboard an amphibious ship at sea.

But the processes to get materials approved for individual use cases has been a protracted one, as the service’s technical authorities, in this case Naval Sea Systems Command, have to vet materials thoroughly before allowing them to be used aboard a ship. The Government Accountability Office has also documented potential cybersecurity risks associated the Pentagon’s use of additive manufacturing.

At least one 3D-printer has “already proven itself shipboard on a handful of aircraft carriers and at least one submarine tender,” Jim Pluta, additive manufacturing program manager for Naval Sea Systems Command, told Breaking Defense in an interview in November.

Ralls, who has worked for HII for 20 years, 10 of which were focused on additive manufacturing, said the long pole in the tent for 3D printing has shifted over time. When he started at HII, the biggest issue was awareness and understanding of what could be achieved.

Today, he said the larger issue has become streamlining the process of qualifying every step associated with using 3D-printed components.

“I think there’s opportunities to accelerate [that streamlining] right now. I think there’s a lot of folks who are working that problem and as those barriers are removed in terms of materials and qualification efficiencies, then I think we’ll see a growth of even more parts deployed,” he said.

PHOTOS: Sea-Air-Space 2023

PHOTOS: Sea-Air-Space 2023

Chesty XVI, the official mascot of the US Marine Corps, took a stroll through the Sea Air Space show floor. His presence raised several questions, among them “who is a good dog,” and “is it you? Are you the good dog?” (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
A Saildrone floats above the show floor at Sea Air Space 2023. Saildrone has become a common tool in the CENTCOM region, and was infamously kidnapped by Iranian forces in 2022. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
AeroVironment’s Switchblade 600 bares its teeth at Sea Air Space. The loitering munition has gotten real-world practice during the Ukraine conflict, as a number of the weapons have been sent from the US to Kyiv. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
The show floor had a steady stream of conference attendees moving to and fro at National Harbor. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
A model of the Kawasaki C-2 transport aircraft is seen on the Sea Air Space 2023 show floor. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
A model of the Kawasaki P-1 Maritime Patrol Aircraft is seen on the Sea Air Space 2023 show floor. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
The largest international pavilion came from the Australian government, which took up a huge chunk of the back of the show floor at Sea Air Space 2023. The event occurs just weeks after details of the new AUKUS submarine deal were announced, tying the US and Aussie navies together as never before. (Aaron Mehta/Breaking Defense)
A model aircraft carrier at Sea Air Space 2023 features General Atomics-made aircraft launch system. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
At Sea Air Space 2023, defense giant Northrop Grumman shows off some maritime-centric missiles. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A model of what appears to be a tilt-rotor uncrewed helicopter is shown at Textron's booth at Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Mike Gilday speaks during a panel comprised of himself, Commandant of the Marine Corps Gen. David H. Berger, Commandant of the Coast Guard Adm. Linda Fagan, and Rear Adm. (Ret.) Ann Phillips during the 2023 Sea-Air-Space Exposition held at the Gaylord National Resort and Convention Center, April 3. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Michael B. Zingaro/Released)
Israel's IAI used a model of a ship to demonstrate it's maritime uncrewed system capabilities at Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A panel of military officials speak on the Future of Warfighting at the Sea-Air-Space 2023 Exposition, held at the Gaylord Convention Center, National Harbor, Maryland, on April 3, 2023. (Photo by Maj. Guster Cunningham III via DVIDS)
Sea Air Space 2023 is all about modern technology. Here's a throwback to the days of ship-to-ship cannon fire from the Naval History and Heritage Command. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A model of a Bell naval ship-to-shore connector hoverboat sits on display at Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A Raytheon-made Tomahawk missile hangs on display at Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A full-sized version of BAE's Amphibious Combat Vehicle rolled onto the show floor for Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
Boeing's Integrator VTOL system lingers above spectators at the defense giant's booth at Sea Air Space 2023. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A model of the Rolls-Royce AE 1107 engine on the Sea Air Space 2023 show floor. The engine is the powerplant for the MV-22, CV-22 and CMV-22 Osprey variants, as well as the engine of choice for the Bell Textron V-280 Valor tiltrotor, which in December won the Army’s Future Long-Range Assault Aircraft (FLRAA) competition to be the successor to the aging UH-60 Black Hawk. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
L3Harris shows off a model of its Navigation Technology Satellite – 3 (NTS-3) satellite at Sea Air Space 2023. Funded through the Air Force Research Laboratory, NTS-3 is designed to test new positioning, timing and navigation (PNT) technologies. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)
A model by Israeli Aerospace Industries at Sea Air Space 2023 shows an uncrewed system coming in for a landing on a ship. (Aaron Mehta / Breaking Defense)