Naval Warfare

Navy’s shipbuilding plan would require massive hike in annual appropriations: CBO

The Navy’s shipbuilding plan released in May would average out to an annual cost of roughly $53.8 billion in shipbuilding appropriations — a 41 percent increase from the last five years, the Congressional Budget Office found.

Part of the aft of the future USS Enterprise (CVN-80) being constructed inside the dry dock at HII’s Newport News Shipbuilding. (Justin Katz/Breaking Defense)

WASHINGTON — The Navy’s 2027 shipbuilding plan would require a massive hike in annual costs in comparison to the average shipbuilding appropriations in recent years, according to a new report from the Congressional Budget Office. 

Specifically, the Navy’s shipbuilding plan released in May would average out to an annual cost of roughly $53.8 billion — totaling a 41 percent increase from the roughly $38.1 billion the Navy has secured annually in appropriations during the last half decade, the CBO report released Thursday said. 

This estimate factors in costs stemming from refueling nuclear-powered ships, and procuring non-battle force ships such as used sealift ships, among other things — costs that are not factored into the Navy’s 2027 shipbuilding plan, even though such expenses are typically derived from shipbuilding funding, CBO said. As a result, those factors increase the CBO’s estimate of the Navy’s average annual shipbuilding costs by roughly $4.6 billion in comparison to the Navy’s shipbuilding plan. Altogether, this marks an unprecedented level of spending for shipbuilding. 

“The cost of the Navy’s 2027 shipbuilding plan is high not only compared with recent funding but also by historical standards,” the report said. “Over the past decade, funding for ship construction has reached its highest levels since the Reagan Administration’s defense buildup in the 1980s. Since 2016, lawmakers have generally appropriated an average of $2.5 billion more per year for shipbuilding than the President has requested, partly because of concerns that the fleet is too small to perform all its missions.” 

Accounting for only purchasing new ships in the recent shipbuilding plan, CBO estimates those ships would rack up to $1.47 trillion in 2026 dollars over 30 years. That’s an increase from the Navy’s estimate of $1.23 trillion over 30 years, per the report. CBO attributed these differences in new ship construction estimates to differences in “assumptions about the design and capabilities of some future ships.” Additionally, CBO acknowledged that it employed different estimating methods and accounted for growth of labor and material costs differently than the Navy. 

The Navy’s shipbuilding plan and budget request seeks a total of $65.8 billion for shipbuilding alone for FY27. To advance the Trump administration’s Golden Fleet initiative, it calls for expanding the Navy’s inventory to 450 ships, including battle force ships, auxiliary ships, and unmanned vessels, by 2031.

“The pace of shipbuilding would be fastest in the next 10 years, reflecting the service’s desire to increase the size of the fleet as quickly as feasible,” the CBO report said. “It would slow from the mid-2030s to the mid-2040s; then construction would ramp up again in the late 2040s and 2050s to replace smaller ships, with a service life of 20 to 25 years, purchased in the first decade of the plan.”

presented by

Meanwhile, the CBO report comes days after the Senate Appropriations defense subcommittee proposed massively slashing the Navy’s shipbuilding budget, trimming roughly $18.5 billion from the Navy’s request. In total, Senate appropriators designated only $41.6 billion to shipbuilding in their proposed spending plan. 

Breaking Defense Video